How an Airplane’s Steady Drone Inspired Robin Gibb to Write the Bee Gees’ Most Haunting Track

By 1968, the Bee Gees had already become international stars.
Barry, Robin and Maurice Gibb had left Australia, returned to Britain and quickly built a reputation for emotional songs, close harmonies and unusually dramatic melodies.
They had already released “New York Mining Disaster 1941.”
“To Love Somebody.”
“Massachusetts.”
But one of their most haunting songs began in a place nobody would normally associate with songwriting.
An airplane.
Robin Gibb later remembered being aboard a British Airways Vickers Viscount somewhere over Europe.
The aircraft had four propeller engines.
Their constant drone filled the cabin.
Most passengers probably heard nothing more than engine noise.
Robin heard music.
As the sound continued, he began imagining a melody inside it.
He said the drone gradually seemed to turn into something resembling a church choir.
That strange sound stayed in his head.
And from it came the beginnings of “I Started a Joke.”
Robin and Barry completed the song together.
The result was unlike a conventional love song.
There was no simple boy-meets-girl story.
Instead, the lyrics described someone whose actions seemed to turn the entire world against him.
He starts a joke.
The world cries.
He begins to cry.
Then the world laughs.
By the end, everything has reversed.
The narrator seems trapped inside his own misunderstanding.
The song never clearly explains exactly what the joke means.
That ambiguity became one of its greatest strengths.
Listeners could hear guilt.
Loneliness.
Alienation.
Regret.
Even something spiritual.
And Robin Gibb’s voice made the uncertainty feel even stronger.
Robin had one of the most distinctive voices in the Bee Gees.
Where Barry could sound smooth and controlled, Robin often sounded fragile and almost trembling.
On “I Started a Joke,” that vulnerability became the center of the recording.
The song appeared on the Bee Gees’ 1968 album Idea.
That album was released during an extraordinarily productive period for the brothers.
They were still very young.
Barry was only in his early twenties.
Robin and Maurice were still teenagers when their international success began.
Yet they were already writing songs with themes that sounded much older.
“I Started a Joke” was one of the clearest examples.
The arrangement was restrained.
Strings surrounded Robin’s voice.
The melody rose and fell with an almost hymn-like quality.
There was nothing aggressive about the performance.
The power came from sadness.
When the song was released as a single in several countries, it became a major hit.
It reached No. 6 on the Billboard Hot 100 in the United States.
It also became a No. 1 hit in countries including Canada and New Zealand.
Strangely, it was not released as a single in the United Kingdom at the time.
That did not stop it from becoming one of the most recognizable songs of the Bee Gees’ early career.
And its reputation continued growing.
Over the decades, many artists recorded their own versions.
The song survived the Bee Gees’ later transformation into disco superstars.
That is important.
When most people think of the Bee Gees today, they may immediately think of Barry Gibb’s falsetto.
“Stayin’ Alive.”
“Night Fever.”
“You Should Be Dancing.”
But the Bee Gees had already lived an entirely different musical life before that sound existed.
In the late 1960s, they were masters of melancholy.
Their songs often sounded mysterious.
Sad.
Almost theatrical.
“I Started a Joke” belonged completely to that earlier world.
It also showed how unusual their songwriting process could be.
They did not always begin with a guitar riff or a piano progression.
Sometimes an idea came from a phrase.
Sometimes from a story.
And once, according to Robin, it came from the repetitive drone of an airplane engine.
That is what makes the story so memorable.
Thousands of people had probably heard the same kind of sound while flying.
To most of them, it was just noise.
Robin Gibb heard a melody.
He carried it away from the flight.
The brothers turned it into a song.
And more than half a century later, “I Started a Joke” still sounds as strange, sad and beautiful as it did in 1968.
Sometimes inspiration does not arrive in a recording studio.
May you like
Sometimes it is already humming around you.
You just have to be the person who hears the song inside the noise.