Chapter 4

The rain started before sunset.
By the time the police cruiser turned onto Briar Lane, every porch light was on, every driveway shone wet, and half the neighborhood had gathered outside despite the cold.
Olivia stood on her porch in her yellow raincoat, soaked through, hair plastered to her cheeks. Her hands shook, but she kept them visible at her sides because too many phones were pointed at her.
Martin Wells stood in front of her with his cracked phone raised inches from her face.
On the screen, doorbell footage played under his trembling thumb.
A figure in a yellow raincoat walked up to Martin’s porch, bent down, and picked up a small medical delivery box. The figure turned away before the camera caught a face.
Martin’s voice broke with rage.
“That package was for my daughter.”
Behind him, Ellie stood in the doorway wrapped in a blanket, her face pale under the porch light. She looked too weak to be outside, but too frightened to go back in.
Olivia looked from the footage to Ellie.
Her stomach turned.
“That isn’t me,” she whispered.
Martin stepped closer.
“You expect me to believe that?”
Neighbors shouted from the driveways.
“She just moved in.”
“That coat looks exactly the same.”
“Check her house.”
Olivia backed into the porch post.
“I never touched your package.”
Martin’s anger was almost unbearable because it came from terror. He was not thinking about blame anymore. He was thinking about the empty space where his daughter’s medicine should have been.
Then Officer Dean Harris stepped between them.
His rain jacket glistened under the police flashers. His bodycam blinked red against his chest. He took Martin’s phone carefully and lowered his voice.
“Mr. Wells, let me look.”
Martin handed it over, still breathing hard.
Officer Harris replayed the video once.
Then he zoomed in.
The yellow raincoat figure turned slightly as it lifted the box.
A small silver pin flashed at the collar.
Harris glanced at Olivia’s raincoat.
No pin.
No mark.
No metal.
May you like
Olivia saw it too.
And across the wet driveway, Carla Voss tilted her umbrella lower, hiding her face.